- Palizzolo – William
- Palladino – Mary Ann
- Palmer – Kenneth
- Palmitesta – Marge (Margaret)
- Parham – Flo (Florence)
- Parsons – Herb (Herbert)
- Pasquerella – Rich (Richard)
- Pecci – Sara Lou
- Pellegrini – Frederick
- Pepe – Dom (Domenic)
- Pesa – Marie
- Pesce – Jean
- Pesce – Lucille
- Petersiel – Paul
- Peterson – Ellen
- Petrino – Ann (Anna)
- Piantedosi – Joanne
- Pino – Dom (Dominick)
- Pizzuto – Marie
- Porcaro – Anthony
- Poste – Edward
- Poste – Rosemarie
- Pothier – Martin
- Potter – Warren